Sam Vaknin’s Instagram Epigrams (archive only)
Narcissism with Vaknin on Instagram (active account)
The behavioral
variability in narcissism and psychopathy is only apparent.
Actually, their behaviors are very consistent and predictable.
RULES
Optimizes allocation of resources, resents when
forced to act wastefully and becomes aggressive, rejecting, frustrating, and
sadistic.
Do you care about me? Narcissist: I do. You are
useful to me. But, don’t you have emotions for me? N: I don’t do emotions. I do
relationship maintenance. I do business: give and take. So, why stay in touch?
N: I owe you. I repay my debts. Plus, you could still be useful.
Example:
If s/he wants to have sex, s/he will turn on
superficial charm, flirt, lovebomb (idealize).
But with the same subject, when s/he cannot have
sex (even though s/he may fervently wish it) s/he will be indifferent,
dismissive, bored, and impatient.
So, motivated strictly by opportunities
(opportunists), not by people, emotions, cognition, or social mores. Loses all
interest when no opportunity presents itself.
Similarly, will disengage physically and mentally
and move on once task accomplished. Will not linger or engage in social
niceties or small talk.
Is utterly uninterested in other people only in
their functions and possible contributions. They cease to exist once their
utility is over, when no longer useful, and are dropped abruptly. Everyone
without exception is instrumentalized and objectified.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
There are great differences of opinion as to what
constitutes the unconscious.
Snippet from a lecture to clinicians in Zagreb,
March 2024. Video courtesy of @reframingtheself
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Narcissist is subject to reverse recency bias: old days bad (victim), morality play (overcoming insurmountable), good (narcissist) prevailed.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Narcissists are traumatized children. They should be treated with a combination of child therapies and trauma interventions and treatments. Snippet from a lecture to clinicians in Zagreb, Croatia, March 2024. Video courtesy of @reframingtheself
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Narcissist knows best, knows it all, and is always right.
Perceives himself as infallible and omniscient. Knowledge emanates only from the inside (intuition and confabulation, internal object, failed othering).
Magical thinking.
Information from the outside suspect because people are either stupid or malevolent and cannot be trusted.
Lacks curiosity about other people and life except when goal-oriented.
Constricted curiosity.
No learning, only syllogisms and deductions (internal rhetoric). Infinite knowledge base to draw on.
Impaired reality testing reframes all data to conform to cognitive distortions and biases and avoid dissonance (internal confirmation bias).
WATCH Narcissist: Bumbling Fool, Incapable of Learning? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8jx3XaZykHY
WATCH Why Narcissist APPEARS So STUPID https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gt6IfAc1a5A
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Will the rise of narcissism undermine hierarchies and replace them with networks? Networks are mirror images of hierarchies: their properties and life cycles directly contravene each other.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
The most egregious form of abuse is self-victimization.
After all: there isn’t much you could do when your
implacable abuser is … YOU.
Still, victimhood as an identity is a form of
narcissism, a cognitive distortion exactly like grandiosity, a grievance-based
entitlement.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Birthday interview with Scott Douglas Jacobsen of In-Sight and Good Men’s Project.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
This video was made in 2018. Nothing has changed
since then. Why do some narcissists appear to be bumbling fools, never mind how intelligent they actually are? Eight reasons:
1. No impulse control, no forethought, no
foresight = counterproductive, self-defeating, and self-destructive decisions
and actions.
2. Acting out: when narcissistic supply is
deficient, narcissists decompensate and go haywire (see:
https://samvak.tripod.com/journal42.html and my post on collapsed narcissists).
3. Pseudo-stupidity: to avoid the consequences of
their misdeeds, narcissists pretend that they have misunderstood something you
have said or done or that you took advantage of their good nature.
4. Gullibility: narcissists are grandiose and
fantasts, so they misjudge reality (impaired reality test), their skills and
limitations, and the intentions of others.
5. No empathy means that the narcissist
disastrously misreads others and behaves in socially unacceptable and clownish
ways.
6. His sense of entitlement renders the narcissist
an overweening buffoon, the butt of mockery and derision, rather than the awe
he believes that he inspires and the respect he thinks that he deserves.
7. Hypervigilance leads to disproportionate
aggression directed at imaginary slights and to persecutory delusions: paranoid
ideation often directed at innocent targets.
8. Finally, the narcissist uses false modesty to
fish for compliments. But his attempts are so transparent and inarticulate, so
fake and manipulative that people react with repulsion and seek to humiliate
him.
The narcissist regards learning something new and
getting advice as narcissistic injuries because both situations imply that he
is not perfect and not omniscient (all-knowing).
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Pathological narcissism is a curse: a severe mental illness that thwarts life, constricts and then destroys it.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Narcissist knows best, knows it all, and is always right.
Perceives himself as infallible and omniscient. Knowledge emanates only from the inside (intuition and confabulation, internal object, failed othering).
Magical thinking.
Information from the outside suspect because people are either stupid or malevolent and cannot be trusted.
Lacks curiosity about other people and life except when goal-oriented.
Constricted curiosity.
No learning, only syllogisms and deductions (internal rhetoric). Infinite knowledge base to draw on.
Impaired reality testing reframes all data to conform to cognitive distortions and biases and avoid dissonance (internal confirmation bias).
Knows best and always right.
WATCH Narcissist: Bumbling Fool, Incapable of Learning? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8jx3XaZykHY
WATCH Why Narcissist APPEARS So STUPID https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gt6IfAc1a5A
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Never mind WHAT the narcissist says, ask yourself WHY s/he says it:
Impression management
Confabulation
Support of grandiosity or shared fantasy
Manipulation
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
There are two possible pathological reactions to childhood abuse and trauma: codependency and narcissism. They both involve fantasy as a defense mechanism: the codependent has a pretty realistic assessment of herself, but her view of others is fantastic; the narcissist’s self-image and self-perception are delusional and grandiose, but his penetrating view of others is bloodcurdlingly accurate (“cold empathy”).
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
My appointment has just been extended as a professor of psychology and management in the Faculty of CIAPS (Commonwealth Institute for Advanced Professional Studies) in the UK (Cambridge and Birmingham), Canada (Ontario), and Nigeria (Lagos). My page in the faculty of CIAPS (scroll to the left) https://ciaps.org/faculty/sam-vaknin/
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
The masses feel that they are being held hostage and
enslaved by rapacious, venal, and mendacious elites.
They regard these elites and their values as
avowed enemies: the West, governments, academia, mainstream media, science, the
finance industry, the Jews.
The foes of the elites are the friends of the
masses: terrorists, antisemites, conspiracy theorists, Russia, China, populist
authoritarians, the alt right, the extreme left.
The masses abuse democracy and empowering
technologies so as to uproot the established order.
This is Jose Ortega y Gasset’s “Revolt of the Masses” which always results in ochlocracies, dictatorships, and
atrocities.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Borderlines and narcissists are a perfect match. How come?
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Narcissists misperceive love and intimacy and mislabel their internal processes.
Full interview: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DjYViKg-nuE
Conor Ryan Eyes Wide Open https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC-9AerUNgK-C3PlOnAchysg
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Presentation in International Congress on Mental Health and Psychiatry, Paris, December 2024
WATCH Haunted Minds of Narcissist, Borderline: Schizoid Empty Core https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qHfYPEf_8ZM
We are all born with empty schizoid core, compensate by introjecting Mommy (symbiosis and primary narcissism).
Borderline's introjection failure and consequent introject inconstancy is what gives rise to his/her sense of emptiness (described by Kernberg). She compensates by over-reliance on external objects (anaclitic personality).
Narcissism is compensatory and infantile: object inconstancy, ceaseless introjection and incorporation of internal object MASK the emptiness, compensate for it (introjective personality).
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
The only form of relevant, helpful psychology amounts to the formulation of insights derived from empathy, observation, and introspection.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
It is debatable whether narcissists are fully human. So many critical features are missing that narcissists resemble machines (or aliens), are closer to artificial intelligence than to what we recognize and designate as human.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Snippet from a lecture to clinicians in Zagreb, Croatia,
March 2024.
Video courtesy of @reframingtheself
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
No ethical consensus regarding what constitutes a
Just War and the permissibility of civilian casualties.
There are international conventions and courts +
domestic laws + Army guidelines.
PSYCHOLOGY OF WAR CRIMES
Bonding and intimacy among combatants, but even
with the enemy which is life-threatening: Objectification, Dehumanization via
splitting and reaction formation, attribution errors.
Paranoid ideation and persecutory delusions.
Self-empowerment, reassertion of control:
Perception of necessary self-defense, greater good, preemption (anxiolytic),
resolution or closure (vengeance, retribution, ledger settling accounts),
righteouness.
Raw purity, exaltation, apotheosis (omnipotence),
catharsis (Colonel Kurz in Apocalypse Now): sadistic, narcissistic psychopaths.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
The only thing I love more than food is more food. Overeating and hoarding (including of money)
are forms of anxiolytic (anxiety-reducing) self-soothing.
Photo courtesy of @reframingtheself
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
It is hard to tell reality and fantasy apart. This is especially true if your mental health is compromised. Here is a tip.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
The narcissist’s victimhood
grievances have to do with appearances: a damaged
reputation, deteriorating looks, time wasted, money lost, declining status, or
mourned past possessions.
A real victim’s grievances have to do with essence: hurt emotions, negative affects,
shattered inner peace, absented sense of safety, inability to trust again, loss
of personal identity, broken dreams and promises.
In the wake of abusive relationships, shame, remorse, and self-recrimination are common. But these should not be confused with the way more healthy processes of introspection, learning from mistakes, and deriving lessons from experience.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
I
peer review book proposals for publishers such as
Routledge and Bloomsbury. I always choose to get paid in books rather than in
cash. Books have always been the only constant in my life, a sanctuary from
horrors and torments, the repository of unrequited attachment, they afforded me
a sense of safety wherever I had ended up, and provided the transmission
mechanism from the slum of my birthplace to the adventures that awaited me
among the rich, the mighty, and the learned.
Photo courtesy of @reframingtheself
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Healing takes way longer than getting sick.
Rebuilding spans years, demolishing requires but a
minute.
Reconstruction demands many more resources than
deconstruction.
Recovery is much more complex than abuse.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Isolophiles
(solophiles) are not schizoid and a few are asexual: they crave solitude, they most enjoy
their own company, and are happiest when engaged in solitary activities.
But, society regards them as weirdos. Well-meaning
people attempt to impose on them companionship and group activities.
Some isolophiles (solophiles) react aggressively
to such incursions. They become misanthropic, cantankerous, ornery, offensive,
haughty, and defensive.
This is a dysfunctional behavioral strategy of
driving everyone away and securing the aloneness the isolophile (solophile)
needs in order to thrive.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
A completely new view of Histrionic Personality Disorder (HPD) is emerging from recent studies. It defies the stereotype.
LITERATURE
WATCH Histrionic Personality Disorder (HPD): Overview and Issues https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Y4B8rgoqDI
Garb HN. Race bias and gender bias in the diagnosis of psychological disorders. Clin Psychol Rev. 2021 Dec;90:102087. doi: 10.1016/j.cpr.2021.102087. Epub 2021 Sep 28. PMID: 34655834.
Eielsen HP, Vrabel K, Hoffart A, Rø Ø, Rosenvinge JH. Reciprocal relationships between personality disorders and eating disorders in a prospective 17-year follow-up study. Int J Eat Disord. 2022 Dec;55(12):1753-1764. doi: 10.1002/eat.23823. Epub 2022 Oct 10. PMID: 36214278; PMCID: PMC10092669.
Maseroli E, Scavello I, Cipriani S, Palma M, Fambrini M, Corona G, Mannucci E, Maggi M, Vignozzi L. Psychobiological Correlates of Vaginismus: An Exploratory Analysis. J Sex Med. 2017 Nov;14(11):1392-1402. doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2017.09.015. PMID: 29110807.
Gillespie NA, Aggen SH, Gentry AE, Neale MC, Knudsen GP, Krueger RF, South SC, Czajkowski N, Nesvåg R, Ystrom E, Rosenström TH, Torvik FA, Reichborn-Kjennerud T, Kendler KS. Testing Genetic and Environmental Associations Between Personality Disorders and Cocaine Use: A Population-Based Twin Study. Twin Res Hum Genet. 2018 Feb;21(1):24-32. doi: 10.1017/thg.2017.73. PMID: 29369040; PMCID: PMC6038923.
González-Bueso V, Santamaría JJ, Oliveras I, Fernández D, Montero E, Baño M, Jiménez-Murcia S, Del Pino-Gutiérrez A, Ribas J. Internet Gaming Disorder Clustering Based on Personality Traits in Adolescents, and Its Relation with Comorbid Psychological Symptoms. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2020 Feb 26;17(5):1516. doi: 10.3390/ijerph17051516. PMID: 32111070; PMCID: PMC7084409.
Yalch MM, Ceroni DB, Dehart RM. Influence of Child Abuse and Neglect on Histrionic Personality Pathology. J Trauma Dissociation. 2023 Jan-Feb;24(1):111-124. doi: 10.1080/15299732.2022.2119458. Epub 2022 Sep 2. PMID: 36053041.
Guillot CR, Lucke HR, Ramsey AJ, Kearns NT, Blumenthal H, Berman ME. Cluster-b personality disorder traits and impulsivity: Indirect associations with alcohol use severity through positive alcohol expectancies. Exp Clin Psychopharmacol. 2023 Apr;31(2):423-432. doi: 10.1037/pha0000598. Epub 2022 Sep 1. PMID: 36048108; PMCID: PMC9975115.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
If you have no ambition, no goals, and no expectations - you can never fail or let yourself down.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
There is no denying that most people want their pets and love them. They are attached to them and experience
grief and bereavement when they die, depart, or are sick. Most pet-owners find
keeping pets emotionally fulfilling, happiness-inducing, and highly satisfying.
This pertains even to unplanned and initially unwanted new arrivals.
Could this be the missing link? Does pet-ownership
revolve around self-gratification? Does it all boil down to the pleasure
principle?
Pet-keeping may, indeed, be habit forming. Months
of raising pups and cubs and a host of social positive reinforcements and
expectations condition pet-owners to do the job. Still, a living pet is nothing
like the abstract concept. Pets wail, soil themselves and their environment,
stink, and severely disrupt the lives of their owners. Nothing too enticing
here.
If you eliminate the impossible, what is left -
however improbable - must be the truth. People keep pets because it provides
them with narcissistic supply.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
The woke liberal left is ostensibly against all
forms of discrimination, racism, and aggression.
But it makes an exception for and legitimizes antisemitism and violence - including sexual violence - against Jews
because, in their eyes, Jews are synonymous with the oppressive and rapacious
elites, maintain a “settler colonial outpost” (Israel), and are, therefore, the
aggressors, never the victims.
Can we end up gaslighting ourselves?
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Most young people are ignorant and illiterate. Their “social activism” and “protests” are nothing but nauseating narcissistic posturing and competitive virtue signaling.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Say this to drive the narcissist to apoplexy, reduce him/her to a quivering heap:
Do this/don’t do this
I agree with you
I disagree with you
I won’t do it
Do you need some help or advice? Directions?
Let me show you how to do it
Maybe, not sure it’s true
Are you sure? Can you prove it? Provide references?
This is one way to look at it/do it
You are wrong, it didn’t happen like that
Maybe s/he is right?
You are among the best
Taking into account … you really did well, look good, are accomplished
I heard this before from someone else
I suggest that you …
I was/am exactly like you, I was thinking precisely the same thing
Together, we will make it
I have the same … like you
Here are a few of the things the narcissist finds devastating:
Any statement or fact, which seems to contradict his inflated perception of his grandiose self.
Any criticism, disagreement, exposure of fake achievements, belittling of "talents and skills" which the narcissist fantasises that he possesses.
Any hint that he is subordinated, subjugated, controlled, owned or dependent upon a third party.
Any description of the narcissist as average and common, indistinguishable from many others.
Any hint that the narcissist is weak, needy, dependent, deficient, slow, not intelligent, naive, gullible, susceptible, not in the know, manipulated, a victim, an average person of mediocre accomplishments.
The narcissist is likely to react with rage to all these and, in an effort to re-establish his fantastic grandiosity, he is likely to expose facts and stratagems he had no conscious intention of exposing.
The narcissist reacts indignantly, with wrath, hatred, aggression, or even overt violence to any infringement of what he perceives to be his natural entitlement.
Narcissists believe that they are so unique and that their lives are of such cosmic significance that others should defer to their needs and cater to their every whim without ado. The narcissist feels entitled to interact or be treated (or questioned) only by unique individuals. He resents being doubted and "ridiculed".
Any insinuation, hint, intimation, or direct declaration that the narcissist is not special at all, that he is average, common, not even sufficiently idiosyncratic to warrant a fleeting interest inflame the narcissist. He holds himself to be omnipotent and omniscient.
Tell the narcissist that he does not deserve the best treatment, that his desires are not everyone's priority, that he is boring or ignorant, that his needs can be catered to by any common practitioner (medical doctor, accountant, lawyer, psychiatrist), that he and his motives are transparent and can be easily gauged, that he will do what he is told, that his temper tantrums will not be tolerated, that no special concessions will be made to accommodate his inflated sense of self, that he is subject to court procedures, etc. – and the narcissist will likely lose control.
The narcissist believes that he is the cleverest, far above the madding crowd.
Contradict him often, disagree with him and criticize his judgement, expose his shortcomings, humiliate and berate him ("You are not as intelligent as you think you are", "Who is really behind all this? It takes sophistication which you don't seem to possess ", "So, you have no formal education", "You are (mistake his age, make him much older)", "What did you do in your life? Did you study? Do you have a degree? Did you ever establish or run a business? Would you define yourself as a success?", "Would your children share your view that you are a good father?", "You were last seen with a certain Ms. … who is (suppressed grin) a stripper (in demeaning disbelief)".
I know that many of these questions cannot be asked outright in a court of law. But you can insinuate them or hurl these sentences at him during the breaks, inadvertently during the examination or deposition phase, etc. Narcissists hate innuendos even more than they detest direct attacks.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Our civilization is utterly narcissistic and becoming gradually more psychopathic. It pays to be narcissistic, it is a positive adaptation.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
A healthy
attitude: “I don’t trust experts just because they are experts. I use my critical thinking.”
A pathological (grandiose) approach: “I don’t
trust experts because I am more knowledgeable than they would ever be.”
(Malignant Egalitarianism).
To trust information just because an expert says
so is a logical fallacy. To distrust information just because it hails from an
expert is envious idiocy.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
3 types of narcissism: post-traumatic (closure),
reactive (attention, need to be seen), societal (conformity) united in charismatic-magnetic
narcissist, the underdog who makes it against all odds and
the elites establishment.
Blank slate that allows projection (“Being There”).
Inordinately lucky (divinely blessed by fate,
supernaturally superhuman, infallible), magical thinking, fantasy as the only
unbounded and unboundaried reality. All wishes can come true, there are no
limits.
Elevates followers (seen, part of history, feel
special or chosen, needed and indispensable) and colludes with them against
others, the “enemy” or the “ill-informed”. Fake hyper-empathy, resonance, mass
intimacy within the cult of the shared fantasy.
Dark side, self-destructiveness owing to
parentification (Bloland, 2000)
LITERATURE
Christopher Bonovitz Psy.D. (2015) Charisma and
Self-
Destruction: A Developmental View, Contemporary
Psychoanalysis, 51:1, 51-73, DOI: 10.1080/00107530.2015.963831
A History of Charisma (2010), John Potts
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
In the discard phase, the narcissist both splits and projects.
Lecture to clinicians in Zagreb, Croatia, March
2024.
Snippet courtesy of @reframingtheself
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Sam Vaknin’s keynote presentation in the International Congress on Mental Health and Psychiatry, December 2024, Paris, France.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Ambition is a form of internalized social control. It renders you just one more rat in the race.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Promiscuity (men and women alike):
Would you buy a used car with 40 previous owners,
never mind how minimal the mileage is?
No, you wouldn’t.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Communicating with the narcissist is not what it seems (or sounds). Listen to @shadowdeangelis
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Men feel less comfortable to admit to having been traumatized - it is perceived as a weakness, a deplorable and ridiculous vulnerability, effete and effeminate. If you have been victimized as a man, something must be wrong with you, maybe you are just stupid, gullible, and you had it coming (you deserve it).
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
The back cover of the first edition of “Malignant Self-love: Narcissism Revisited”, the first book ever written about narcissistic abuse (published online in 1997 and in a print edition 1999). Nothing much new has been added since then.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
YOLO=You
Only Live Once, WOLF=We Only Live Forever.
No Ego, No Superego, Only Id.
No horizon: no future consequences to present actions
(malignant mindfulness), sense of impunity and immunity (will always get away
with it).
Opportunities perceives as malfunctions of reality
and the resulting disequilibrium must be seized regardless of costs or
consequences (carpe diem).
Lack of impulse control, disinhibition,
attentional narrowing.
Rise of narcissism in modern civilization renders
other people a burden or even dangerous.
Narcissists and psychopaths are over-represented
in mission critical professions.
Narcissists and psychopaths in the family and
among friends, on dating and in the workplace makes self-sufficient atomization
and solitude the only survival strategy if one abjures narcissism.
Schizoid men saw the business opportunity in such
social trends and developed technologies that are asocial, mislabeling them as
social.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
People are not interested in nuances, shades of
grey, doubts, or in the truth.
They engage in splitting within a morality
play: all good vs. irredeemably evil, totally right
vs. absolutely wrong, impeccable heroes or victims vs. malevolent predators and
monsters.
And guess on whose side they always find
themselves.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Narcissist has no ego and, therefore, no superego which is a part of the ego.
Primitive superego injunctions=negative introjects within an internalized bad object.
Bad object is internalized and incorporated by the child, it is not the mother (departure from Klein).
LITERATURE
WATCH You Don't Deserve to Be Happy, Loved (Bad Object) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TTGaesM987o
WATCH Ego is Opposite of Narcissism: Ego Functions https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bVjbnJLK4fQ
Taming the Negative Introject: Empowering Patients to Take Control of Their Mental Health, by Carol Berman, 2019
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
The narcissist is possessed by an internalized bad object: a coalition of disparaging, shaming, and hateful voices
(negative introjects).
The bad object IS the narcissist. The narcissist
compensates for the bad object by becoming someone else (by merging with a
False Self).
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Kathi Stringer, a mental health educator and author, was among the very first to spread the word about my work on narcissistic abuse in the 1990s through her website. To express her commitment to these then new ideas about narcissism, she purchased 100 copies of the first edition of “Malignant Self-love: Narcissism Revisited” (I have never charged for any of my content online). A few days ago, she sent me this song and I am sharing it with you.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Why the powerful bond with the narcissist? Why
does invariably devalue and discard you?
Common background of ACEs (Adverse Childhood
Experiences)
Hall of Mirrors Effect
Trauma Bonding
Shared Fantasy
Projective Resonance (not the same as empathy or
social cognition):
As an external object, if you are weak, vulnerable, dependent, and submissive, you
remind him of his moribund True (unconstellated, unintegrated) Self (and,
thereby, undermine his grandiose, fantastic False Self).
As an external object, if you are strong,
resilient, agentic, independent, and self-efficacious you remind him of his
False Self (and, thereby, challenge his uniqueness).
This is another reason for snapshotting
(introjecting) you. While you are a threat to the narcissist’s precarious
balance, as an internal object you make him feels whole, elated, oceanic when
reminded of his True Self - or idealized (co-idealization) when you remind him
of his False Self.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
The ideal in ages past was the Jack of All Trades, the Renaissance
Man, with an all-rounded education, forged in the crucible of innovation and
discovery.
Nowadays, we aspire to be specialists, money
hungry experts on a tiny sliver of knowledge, oblivious to all else. We often
fake even such alleged competence.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Victimhood movements on both the left and the right show signs of mental illness. With Ed Dutton (https://edwarddutton.com/)
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
An overview of narcissism and the narcissist in my interview on the Theory of Everything YouTube channel with Curt Jaimungal.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
The secret to self-actualization is balance and transparency with yourself and with others. Swipe left!
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
The narcissist’s shared fantasy
is a form of lucid dreaming, it is his lucid dream and
you are just a character in it, manipulated according to a pre-ordained script.
The narcissist incorporates you into the shared
fantasy by entraining you and this process triggers introjects and repressed
memories.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Narcissistic female CEOs and narcissistic CFO are good for business: they enhance the performance, profitability, and valuation of the enterprises they manage.
More and more women join the ranks of narcissists and psychopaths. A recent study found that female narcissistic CEOs outbest their narcissistic male counterparts in every corporate yardstick.
LITERATURE
Female CEOs with a squeeze of narcissism: A
perfect cocktail for corporate performance? by Tom Aabo, Sara Korsdal Rønnow
Finance Research Letters, Volume 64, June 2024,
105469
CFO narcissism and corporate digital
transformation by Wenyun Yao, Mengjiao Ni, Yuhang Qian, Shujing Yang, Xiaona Cui,
Finance Research Letters, Volume 64, June 2024, 105422
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
The rush to rebound from narcissistic abuse is counterproductive, even destructive.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Abuse
is normalized in early childhood, it becomes a comfort zone,
love is associated with pain.
In in my interview on the Theory of Everything
YouTube channel with Curt Jaimungal.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
This is how AI imagines and visualizes my mind, based on my talk with Dr. Martin Burckhardt. Swipe left.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
More and more women join the ranks of narcissists and psychopaths. A recent study found that female narcissistic CEOs outbest their narcissistic male counterparts in every corporate yardstick.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Infantilization: language, tone of voice.
Regresses you as well: two orphans in the dark
woods (Hansel and Gretel Effect).
Fight for the relationship (like not divorcing
because of the kids).
True self never emerges, bait into shared fantasy,
a lure.
No Inner child. Narcissist is a child (arrested
development, developmental delay, disorder).
Developmental age (DA), developmental amnesia,
maturational crisis.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
It is amazing how often unmitigated
idiots (think Elon Musk) are eulogized by towering intellects.
Example: Bismarck ruined the balance of power in
Europe that guaranteed peace for decades. He introduced military might as the
arbiter in international affairs. He destroyed the Holy Alliance and then had
to recreate it from scratch. He fathered the two world wars that devastated the
Continent and, most of all, his beloved Germany.
Yet, Kissinger called him a genius.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Love and time are risks, not opportunities. And, yet, life is pointless without both.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Being a Jew is a life sentence which I am proud to bear. Interview with Conor Ryan, Eyes Wide Open.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
There are many ways to circumvent and sabotage
the no
contact with your abuser rules:
Frivolous litigation
Rebuttal: privately and in public
Stalking, intelligence gathering, and messaging:
direct and indirect (via third parties and go-betweens, including common
children, on social media)
Signaling and encoded messages
Reframing and inner dialog with introject
Smear campaigning
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
The only two keys to becoming combination Elon Musk and Donald Trump!
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Suffering
and loss are misperceived as ...
Secure base: safe, predictable, familiar,
ritualized (religious).
Self-punitive, resonates with introjects as way to
silence bad object.
Expiating, purging, cleansing and therefore
rewarding or leads to rewards (morality play and moral superiority).
Victimhood identity confers rights and
entitlements.
Engine of personal growth and development,
identity formation.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Growing awareness of narcissism and psychopathy
since the 1960s makes it more difficult to prey on victims. I was the first to
describe narcissistic abuse in 1995 and this launched a global movement.
Narcissists and psychopaths transitioned from hunting to virtual reality: shared fantasies that have
redefined civilization in narcissistic and psychopathic terms.
The new ecosystem rewards and incentivizes
narcissistic and psychopathic traits and behaviors and promotes them
(axiological shift): ambition, ruthlessness, callousness, defiance,
contumaciousness, Machiavellianism (manipulativeness), atomization (self-sufficiency).
This new ecosystem is binary. There are only 2
roles available: predator and prey. Your choice. This guarantees an abundance
of prey – but it also promotes victimhood and paranoia which, ironically, are
forms of grandiosity.
Victimhood and paranoia created an imbalance
between the number of victims and the number of abusers. So, victims are now in
search of abusers: they label everyone as a victimizer by redefining abuse and
lowering the bar of what constitutes abuse.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Mistaken application of concept of peers only to children or adolescents.
WATCH When Narcissist is Rejected by Peers https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JYPLw5P3jSU
Peers are not always primary (supportive) group, though they constitute a social group with shared interests and values (homophily). Sometimes, they are frenemies. Always they are a point of reference which induces both ego syntony and ego dystony, or even suicidal ideation.
Peer groups thrive on othering failures and collective negative identity formation. Exclusion (e.g., unisex, unigender) and hierarchy (dominance vs. submission) provide a sense of safety, popularity, wellbeing, and defiant autonomy.
Peers are socialization agents and the conveyors and purveyors of social and sexual behavioral scripts via peer pressure and modeling. Social referents for teaching other members customs, social norms, gender roles, and different ideologies.
Lack of affiliation to a peer group alters cognitive, linguistic, social, and emotional paths of development Lev Vygotsky’s sociocultural theory, Jean Piaget’s theory of cognitive development, Erik Erikson’s stages of psychosocial development, Harry Stack Sullivan’s Theory of Interpersonal Relations).
Piaget: children’s speech less egotistical among themselves than with adults.
Sullivan described friendships as providing the following functions: (a) offering consensual validation, (b) bolstering feelings of self-worth, (c) providing affection and a context for intimate disclosure, (d) promoting interpersonal sensitivity, and (e) setting the foundation for romantic and parental relationships.
Decreasing dependence on parents, increasing feelings of self-sufficiency, and connecting with a much larger social network.
John B. Watson, B.F. Skinner, and Albert Bandura, Judith Rich Harris, Behaviourism, Operant Learning Theory, and Cognitive Social Learning Theory.
Social Identity Theory: group norms are developed and enforced through socialization processes that promote in-group similarity (normative regulation coupled with the practice of social behaviors via assigned roles) and superiority or victimhood (halo effect via affiliation).
Peer groups' cohesion is determined and maintained by such factors as group communication, group consensus (normative code), and group conformity concerning attitude and behavior.
Peer groups also sanction non-conformity (e.g., by rejection) and thus motivate risk-taking (recklessness), aggression, promiscuity, but also prosociality rather than antagonism and dissociality.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Andre Green’s concept of the “dead mother” (the opposite of Winnicott’s “good enough mother”) explains the pathoetiology of narcissism.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Say this to drive the narcissist to apoplexy, reduce him/her to a quivering heap:
Do this/don’t do this
I agree with you
I disagree with you
I won’t do it
Do you need some help or advice? Directions?
Let me show you how to do it
Maybe, not sure it’s true
Are you sure? Can you prove it? Provide references?
This is one way to look at it/do it
You are wrong, it didn’t happen like that
Maybe s/he is right?
You are among the best
Taking into account … you really did well, look good, are accomplished
I heard this before from someone else
I suggest that you …
I was/am exactly like you, I was thinking precisely the same thing
Together, we will make it
I have the same … like you
Here are a few of the things the narcissist finds devastating:
Any statement or fact, which seems to contradict his inflated perception of his grandiose self.
Any criticism, disagreement, exposure of fake achievements, belittling of "talents and skills" which the narcissist fantasises that he possesses.
Any hint that he is subordinated, subjugated, controlled, owned or dependent upon a third party.
Any description of the narcissist as average and common, indistinguishable from many others.
Any hint that the narcissist is weak, needy, dependent, deficient, slow, not intelligent, naive, gullible, susceptible, not in the know, manipulated, a victim, an average person of mediocre accomplishments.
The narcissist is likely to react with rage to all these and, in an effort to re-establish his fantastic grandiosity, he is likely to expose facts and stratagems he had no conscious intention of exposing.
The narcissist reacts indignantly, with wrath, hatred, aggression, or even overt violence to any infringement of what he perceives to be his natural entitlement.
Narcissists believe that they are so unique and that their lives are of such cosmic significance that others should defer to their needs and cater to their every whim without ado. The narcissist feels entitled to interact or be treated (or questioned) only by unique individuals. He resents being doubted and "ridiculed".
Any insinuation, hint, intimation, or direct declaration that the narcissist is not special at all, that he is average, common, not even sufficiently idiosyncratic to warrant a fleeting interest inflame the narcissist. He holds himself to be omnipotent and omniscient.
Tell the narcissist that he does not deserve the best treatment, that his desires are not everyone's priority, that he is boring or ignorant, that his needs can be catered to by any common practitioner (medical doctor, accountant, lawyer, psychiatrist), that he and his motives are transparent and can be easily gauged, that he will do what he is told, that his temper tantrums will not be tolerated, that no special concessions will be made to accommodate his inflated sense of self, that he is subject to court procedures, etc. – and the narcissist will likely lose control.
The narcissist believes that he is the cleverest, far above the madding crowd.
Contradict him often, disagree with him and criticize his judgement, expose his shortcomings, humiliate and berate him ("You are not as intelligent as you think you are", "Who is really behind all this? It takes sophistication which you don't seem to possess ", "So, you have no formal education", "You are (mistake his age, make him much older)", "What did you do in your life? Did you study? Do you have a degree? Did you ever establish or run a business? Would you define yourself as a success?", "Would your children share your view that you are a good father?", "You were last seen with a certain Ms. … who is (suppressed grin) a stripper (in demeaning disbelief)".
I know that many of these questions cannot be asked outright in a court of law. But you can insinuate them or hurl these sentences at him during the breaks, inadvertently during the examination or deposition phase, etc. Narcissists hate innuendos even more than they detest direct attacks.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
The internalized or introjected bad object is a coalition of inner hateful voices that inform the child that s/he is unlovable, unworthy, inadequate, a failure, ugly, and stupid. The child internalizes the bad object so as to maintain an image of his/her mother as all good (splitting defense). A bad or “dead” mother is detrimental to the child’s survival, so the child refuses to even contemplate such a possibility. The child says: I am all bad and deserve my punishment - Mommy is always all good, infallible, and flawless. Image courtesy of @mirna_liz37
This is how @mirna_liz37 visualizes the internalized (introjected) bad object.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
As I have been insisting for 3 decades, mental illness is transmissible, contagious, infectious. This is also true with personality disorders.
LITERATURE
WATCH Narcissism Virus: Genes, Deception, Brain, Mind (Compilation) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pGHjTwqbcvw
WATCH Narcissism Virus Vaccine NOW: It Evades Your Immunity! Real Pandemic Is Here! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uczI-m4Zb9o
Alho J, Gutvilig M, Niemi R, et al. Transmission of Mental Disorders in Adolescent Peer Networks. JAMA Psychiatry. Published online May 22, 2024. doi:10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2024.1126
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Dr.
Fauci committed mistakes during the pandemic. I was
one of his earliest critics on camera.
But when a semi-literate white trash politician
screams at one of the most preeminent medical scholars of our time: “You are
not a doctor”, you know that the end of civilization and the beginning of the
era of moronic psychopathic narcissists are upon us.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
We often marvel at the discrepancy between the
private and public lives of our idols: celebrities,
statesmen, stars, writers, and other accomplished figures. It is as though they
have two personalities, two selves: the “true” one which they reserve for their
nearest and dearest and the “fake” or “false” or “concocted” one which they flaunt
in public.
In contrast, the narcissist has no private life,
no true self, no domain reserved exclusively for his nearest and dearest. His
life is a spectacle, with free access to all, constantly on display, garnering
narcissistic supply from his audience. In the theatre that is the narcissist’s
life, the actor is irrelevant. Only the show goes on.
The False Self is everything the narcissist would
like to be but, alas, cannot: omnipotent, omniscient, invulnerable,
impregnable, brilliant, perfect, in short: godlike. Its most important role is
to elicit narcissistic supply from others: admiration, adulation, awe,
obedience, and, in general: unceasing attention. In Freud’s tripartite model,
the False Self supplants the Ego and conforms to the narcissist’s unattainable,
grandiose, and fantastic Ego Ideal.
Continued: http://www.narcissistic-abuse.com/faq48.html
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Introjection
(regression to womb-matrix, infancy): snapshotting installs Trojan Horse in narcissist’s mind
Repetition and entraining:
Grandiosity challenging
Ideational misattribution
Feigned helplessness (savior/rescuer)
Mass psychegenic (cult)
Ego syntonic narrative with survival (positive)
adaptation (motivation to introject and assimilate narrative): anxiolytic
(separation insecurity (abandonment anxiety)); triumphant-antagonistic (e.g.,
justice restored, omnipotence affirmed); grandiosity-enhancing and
grandiosity-congruent.
Your flying monkeys: peer dynamics and hive mind,
the in group or cult personality (outsourcing of cognitive processes and
acquiring a social identity): belonging and acceptance (surrogate family),
self-worth, modeling, peer pressure, operant conditioning, normative
regulation, negative identity, social referents.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
As a child, the narcissist’s positive
emotions (such as love) often resulted in hurt,
rejection, abandonment, exploitation, and abuse.
His/her negative emotions (e.g, anger in temper
tantrum) typically proved to be self-efficacious (led to favorable outcomes).
So, growing up, the narcissist has learned to
repress (bury) his/her positive affects and experience consciously only the
negative ones.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Infantilization: language, tone of voice. Lures you into the shared fantasy
by harping on your maternal instincts.
Regresses you as well: two orphans in the dark
woods (Hansel and Gretel Effect).
Fight for the relationship (like not divorcing
because of the kids).
True self never emerges, bait into shared fantasy,
a lure.
No Inner child. Narcissist is a child (arrested
development, developmental delay, disorder).
Developmental age (DA), developmental amnesia,
maturational crisis.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Another indispensable @shadowdeangelis capsule, this time about “snapshotting”.
The narcissist is capable of having pseudointimate
relationships that do not involve a shared fantasy. In such liaisons, he is
indifferent and dismissive, but not abusive.
Within a shared fantasy, the narcissist snapshots
(introjects) his partner and then idealizes the resultant internal object.
Henceforth, the narcissist abusively coerces his
partner into conforming to this inner representation of her (avatar) in his
mind.
This course of action guarantees the ultimate
dissolution of the bond via devaluation and discard and the long sought after
separation from a maternal figure.
The narcissist’s partners end up abandoning him,
triangulating or mortifying him with infidelity or other forms of betrayal in a
desperate attempt to jump start the moribund relationship (a cry for help,
having been exposed to the narcissist’s inexorable betrayal fantasy), or
succumbing and becoming a figment in his fantasy.
When his partner consents to suspend her autonomy
and agency and give in to the shared fantasy, separation-individuation fails.
Resentful and frustrated, the narcissist
defeminizes and maternalizes the obsequious partner: the relationship becomes
sexless and transactional.
She becomes a full-fledged mother figure, free to
have sex and romance with others, but always at the beck and call of the
permanently infantilized narcissist.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Video presentation in 4th World Congress of Psychiatrists and Psychologist in Paris, June 2024. The topic: “Narcissists under Pressure in Peer Groups”.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
In the 1980 Japanese sci-fi film “Virus”,
millions protest violently and RATIONALLY demand to be inoculated with a new
vaccine against the ravages of a lethal pandemic.
Fast forward to 2021 when millions demonstrated
violently AGAINST being inoculated with new vaccines and doubted the very
existence of a virus or the fatal disease it wrought.
This difference between the two periods is, in a
nutshell, why humanity is doomed.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Only correct response to smear campaign: no response.
Damage to reputation non-existent among true friends
and just workplaces, great among fake ones. So, smear campaign is a useful
filter or membrane.
Turning an agent into an asset (double agent) in
counterintelligence.
Appear collaborative and compliant, thank the
flying monkey, act as if you are scared in order to elicit additional info and
lower the guard of the conspirators.
Feed the narcissist with wrong info,
disinformation (with nuggets of truth).
Spy on the narcissist and anticipate his/her next
moves.
Identify others involved in the conspiracy of the
campaign.
Expose the narcissist’s often criminal conspiracy
to law enforcement, media, or online.
Alternatively, keep the evidence against the
narcissist and his flying monkeys for future use in case of extortion.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
A narcissist parent is a narcissist first and a parent last.
Your narcissist child is a narcissist first and
foremost and your child only as an afterthought.
A narcissist friend is a narcissist first and
never your friend.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Narcissism is an absence masquerading as a presence. The narcissist fails to integrate his/her self as a child, has no ego. Narcissists reconstruct themselves on the fly as they go along.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Even abuse is better than
loneliness?
NOT! Abuse is the worst, most egregious and
extreme form of loneliness!
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Bad
memories are the tuition fee we pay in order to learn
from our mistakes and grow.
Narcissists and borderlines are dissociative: they
have vast memory gaps and are, therefore, incapable of growth and learning.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
The codependent's inner parent feels betrayed when the codependent falls in love. It pushes the codependent to punish her partner as a loyalty test, to placate the implacable inner parent. Riven by guilt and shame, the codependent then punishes herself as well. This is a borderline dynamic.
Codependents and their intimate partners engage in co-regulation (via symbiotic merger/fusion).
The codependent suffers from object inconstancy, separation insecurity aka abandonment anxiety, and catastrophizing. She seeks to attach to a secure base via people-pleasing, control from the bottom and emotional blackmail (an external object), and aggression directed at an internal object.
The codependent outsources her ego functions, such as reality testing.
The codependent feels alive only when in a relationship, she maintains a vicarious life. In solitude, she finds her constricted life intolerable. She loves herself by proxy, through the gaze and agency of her intimate partner.
Daria Zukowska's YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCl_hm5r5Osb818eIB5t7j-g
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Narcissists appropriate other people’s lives and then try to get rid of the evidence in every way possible by getting rid of you.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
On Vistel TV (vtv.mk) in Skopje, North Macedonia at 17:15 local time. Going to talk to the veteran journalist, Slobodan Tomik @slobodantomik about Israel’s war in Gaza, parliamentary elections in the EU, Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, China and the USA. For more, see my vakninmusings YouTube channel.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Black hole in autistic children first suggest by Frances Tustin in 1972.
Metaphors of narcissisms and borderline personalities: rot, vampire, virus, cancer, black hole, quantum objects (uncertainty and information)
Bad memories are the tuition fee we pay in order to learn from our mistakes and grow. Narcissists and borderlines are dissociative: they have vast memory gaps and are, therefore, incapable of growth and learning.
Quick scramblers
LITERATURE
WATCH Why the Emptiness in Borderlines, Narcissists? (Introjection Failure and Compulsive Introjection) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NuLf1gvOLq8
WATCH Haunted Minds of Narcissist, Borderline: Schizoid Empty Core https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qHfYPEf_8ZM
WATCH No Identity Without Memory (Lecture for Southern Federal University, Rostov-on-Don) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E1TudmLThyA
Black holes scramble information – but may not be the best at it, New Scientist, https://www.newscientist.com/article/2429489-black-holes-scramble-information-but-may-not-be-the-best-at-it/
The ‘black hole’: a significant element in autism, Frances Tustin,
(1988).Free Associations,1L(11):35-50
Eshel O. 'Black holes', deadness and existing analytically. Int J Psychoanal. 1998 Dec;79 ( Pt 6):1115-30. PMID: 10036623.
Clark, G. "A black hole in psyche." Harvest 29 (1983): 67-80.
The “Black Hole” as the Basic Psychotic Experience: Some Newer Psychoanalytic and Neuroscience Perspectives on Psychosis
James S. Grotstein
Journal of the American Academy of Psychoanalysis Vol. 18, No. 1, March 1990
https://doi.org/10.1521/jaap.1.1990.18.1.29
'Black holes': escaping the void, Sharn Waldron 1
J Anal Psychol, . 2013 Feb;58(1):99-117. doi: 10.1111/j.1468-5922.2013.02019.x.
Pecotic, B. (2002). The “black hole” in the inner universe. Journal of Child Psychotherapy, 28(1), 41–52. https://doi.org/10.1080/00754170110116736